This restaurant is a well-established and popular spot for breakfast on Ocracoke Island. With a cozy and casual atmosphere, it's a great place to start your day with a delicious meal. The service is usually friendly and attentive, with many reviewers praising the staff for their excellent service. The menu offers a wide range of options, including American classics like pancakes, eggs, and bacon, as well as some unique dishes like crab and Swiss omelets. The food is generally well-prepared and tasty, although some reviewers have noted that the portions can be small for the price. One potential issue to be aware of is the fact that the restaurant can be quite busy, especially during peak season, which may lead to a wait for a table. However, the staff does a good job of managing the crowds and getting orders out quickly. Overall, Pony Island Restaurant is a great choice for breakfast on Ocracoke Island, offering a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and a variety of tasty options. Just be prepared for a potentially busy experience and a slightly higher price point than some other breakfast spots.