business or service...
Open Now
Sort by:

Mahi Mahi's Island Grill

4.3
• (1 reviews)
2217 S Croatan Hwy Highway, Nags Head
|
5.87
mil
2217 S Croatan Hwy Highway, Nags Head
|
5.87
mil
See All photos
Overview
Overview
Features
Features
Photos
Photos
Direction

Features

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Takeout
Dine-in
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Hard liquor
Wine
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Restroom
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace
Accepts reservations
Free parking lot
Parking
LGBTQ+ friendly
Lunch

Photos & videos

See All
Reviews
All our ratings are from genuine customers

Submit a review

4.3
1 reviews
Overall
4.3
Quality
3.5
Pricing
4.0
Innovativeness
4.0

Submit a review

Synergy AI assistant
Tue, Oct 14, 2025
4.3
Based on reviews, Mahi Mahi's Island Grill is a good option for those looking for a casual dining experience with a focus on seafood. The restaurant has received praise for its friendly staff, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere. However, some reviewers have noted that the service can be slow, and the quality of the food has been inconsistent.The restaurant's location on the Outer Banks makes it a great spot for families and those looking for a beach-town vibe. The menu features a variety of seafood options, including fish, shrimp, and oysters, as well as non-seafood options for those who prefer. The prices are generally reasonable, with most meals falling in the $20-$30 range.One of the standout features of Mahi Mahi's Island Grill is its commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. This is reflected in the high quality of the food, particularly the seafood options. However, some reviewers have noted that the quality of the food can be inconsistent, with some dishes being overcooked or underseasoned.The restaurant's atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with a focus on providing a relaxed and casual dining experience. The outdoor seating area is a great spot to enjoy a meal on a nice day, and the staff is friendly and attentive.Overall, Mahi Mahi's Island Grill is a good option for those looking for a casual dining experience with a focus on seafood. While the service can be slow and the quality of the food can be inconsistent, the restaurant's commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and its welcoming atmosphere make it a great choice for families and those looking for a beach-town vibe.The major issue that needs to be addressed is the inconsistent quality of the food, with some reviewers noting that dishes can be overcooked or underseasoned. This is a major concern for a restaurant that prides itself on using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.
Location
Location
Location
Phone
Phone
2217 S Croatan Hwy Highway, Nags Head
Get Directions

Own this business?

Claim it now to update information, respond to reviews, and connect with customers.
Claim This Business
Contact business

Categories

Restaurants & Catering
Restaurants
American Restaurants
Restaurant

Contact business

Name
Email
Phone
Message
Send Message
Sponsored
Chatbot minimized icon1

FOR BUSINESS

FIND US ON SOCIAL

©
2026
OBXTide. All rights reserved.